A detailed comparison of Bollywood remakes and their original versions. Find out which movies did better and why some remakes failed to impress audiences.
Bollywood has a long history of remaking movies, both from its own archives and from foreign films. While some remakes successfully recreate the magic of the original, others fail to capture the essence. In this blog, we will compare Bollywood remakes with their original versions and see which ones turned out better.
Why Does Bollywood Love Remakes?
Bollywood producers remake movies for several reasons:
- Proven Storyline: If a movie is already a hit, it has a better chance of succeeding again.
- Modern Audience Appeal: Some old classics are remade to suit contemporary tastes.
- Regional Adaptation: Many South Indian films are remade for a wider Hindi-speaking audience.
- Better Technology & Effects: Older movies lacked advanced CGI and cinematography, which remakes can improve.
Bollywood Remakes That Outshined the Originals
While remakes often receive criticism, some have surpassed the original in storytelling, acting, and production quality. Here are a few examples:
1. Don (2006) vs. Don (1978)
- Original: Amitabh Bachchan’s Don was a cult classic with a gripping storyline and memorable dialogues.
- Remake: Shah Rukh Khan’s Don added a modern twist, improved action sequences, and a shocking climax that made it stand apart.
- Verdict: The remake brought a fresh take, making it equally loved.
2. Agneepath (2012) vs. Agneepath (1990)
- Original: Amitabh Bachchan’s Agneepath had strong emotions but underperformed at the box office.
- Remake: Hrithik Roshan’s Agneepath had stunning cinematography, intense performances, and a powerful villain (Sanjay Dutt as Kancha Cheena).
- Verdict: The remake performed better commercially and emotionally connected more with audiences.
3. Kabir Singh (2019) vs. Arjun Reddy (2017)
- Original: The Telugu film Arjun Reddy starred Vijay Deverakonda and became a blockbuster.
- Remake: Shahid Kapoor’s Kabir Singh followed the same storyline but became an even bigger hit in Bollywood.
- Verdict: The remake had better music and a broader appeal, making it more successful.
Bollywood Remakes That Failed to Impress
Not all remakes do well. Some lose the magic of the original and end up being a disappointment. Here are some examples:
1. Ram Gopal Varma Ki Aag (2007) vs. Sholay (1975)
- Original: Sholay is one of the greatest Bollywood movies, featuring an unforgettable cast and storyline.
- Remake: Ram Gopal Varma Ki Aag was a disastrous attempt, with weak dialogues and poor direction.
- Verdict: The remake was a disaster and failed miserably.
2. Karzzzz (2008) vs. Karz (1980)
- Original: Rishi Kapoor’s Karz was a musical thriller with evergreen songs.
- Remake: Himesh Reshammiya’s Karzzzz lacked strong performances and failed to recreate the same emotional depth.
- Verdict: The original remains a fan favorite, while the remake was forgettable.
3. Zanjeer (2013) vs. Zanjeer (1973)
- Original: Amitabh Bachchan’s Zanjeer established him as the ‘Angry Young Man.’
- Remake: The 2013 remake starring Ram Charan lacked the same intensity and impact.
- Verdict: The remake failed to match the original’s iconic appeal.
The South Indian Film Influence on Bollywood Remakes
Bollywood has remade many successful South Indian films. Some of these remakes worked well, while others did not.
Successful South to Bollywood Remakes:
- Wanted (2009) – Remake of Telugu film Pokiri (2006), became a blockbuster.
- Drishyam (2015) – Remake of Malayalam film Drishyam (2013), received high praise.
- Rowdy Rathore (2012) – Remake of Telugu film Vikramarkudu (2006), turned into a super hit.
Flop South to Bollywood Remakes:
- Laxmii (2020) – Remake of Tamil film Kanchana, failed to impress.
- Simmba (2018) – Inspired by Temper, but did not match the original’s intensity.
- Ok Jaanu (2017) – Remake of O Kadhal Kanmani, but lacked emotional depth.
Hollywood to Bollywood Remakes
Bollywood has also remade several Hollywood films. Some were well-executed, while others fell flat.
Successful Hollywood to Bollywood Remakes:
- Sarkar (2005) – Inspired by The Godfather (1972), adapted well to Indian politics.
- Kaante (2002) – Inspired by Reservoir Dogs (1992), became a cult hit.
- Ghajini (2008) – Inspired by Memento (2000), but with a stronger emotional connection.
Flop Hollywood to Bollywood Remakes:
- Players (2012) – Inspired by The Italian Job (2003), but lacked thrills.
- Bang Bang! (2014) – Inspired by Knight and Day (2010), but lacked chemistry.
- God Tussi Great Ho (2008) – Inspired by Bruce Almighty (2003), but failed to entertain.
Why Do Some Remakes Fail?
Some Bollywood remakes fail due to the following reasons:
- Weak Adaptation: Some remakes do not capture the essence of the original.
- Poor Casting: The actors may not fit the roles as well as the original actors.
- Lack of Innovation: If the remake is too similar, audiences see no reason to watch it.
- Overhyping: High expectations can lead to disappointment if the film doesn’t deliver.
Conclusion: Are Remakes Worth It?
Bollywood remakes can be both a hit or a miss. While some remakes bring a fresh perspective and attract new audiences, others fail to match the charm of the originals. Ultimately, the success of a remake depends on its execution, performances, and how well it adapts the story for a modern audience.
What do you think? Do you prefer Bollywood remakes or the originals? Let us know in the comments!
